beakie
NAXJA Forum User
- Location
- Ontario, Canada
NCCherokee said:I've never tried the whole braking in neutral thing, but i'll give it a shot this winter to compare. In the deep stuff i've always driven in 4lo and i always drop it into first gear and 4 lo. It bites hard but NEVER breaks loose. and i feel i have more control.
In regards to your comment, i dont know about you, but whenever i'm coming down a steep face or hill, i'm in 4lo first gear. Try it. Go down a face in 4lo, first gear, and you can crawl down (if your gearing is good). Do the same thing, but put it in neutral, and see what is easier to brake/control.
Thats why i use this same reasoning when "engine braking" in the snow. But like i said, i'll give it a shot.
oh, and someone else said that engine braking doesnt work at slow speeds around 10mph, but it in 4lo and first, it will bite like hell at this speed. Again, i usually drive in 4lo in the deep stuff so that i can control my speed better.
I whole heartedly agree you will move slower downhill in 1st, 4lo or whatever gear really, it won't allow to tires to roll as fast.
But as you said (bold print) 'it bites hard' and thats with tires probably deflated a bit, 12" wide and on dry rock or dirt. But when you do this on snow/ice/slippery roads that bite has nothing to bite into, properly inflated tires wet or cold icy roads and that hard bite will cause your tires to slip a bit. I am not saying it means you loose control and ditch it everytime, hopefully it never happens, I just mean you have to be more careful of how you downshift while on these type of roads. I never knew the extent of it until a car full of us ended up in the ditch after a light snow on a steep hill.
I'm glad you'll give it a shot this coming winter, if it works for you, its another feather in your hat and a helpful way to stay out of trouble, if it doesn't and you don't feel it helps you at all... well life is no worse off and you have an educated personal experience that not everyone else on here has.