Wishing now I would have done 4.88s for two reasons.
1st reason fuel economy at lower speed.
I get my best fuel econ at about 2700rpm which runs me about 73-75 mph, if I drive slower like 60-65mph my mpg goes to 13 avr. My jeep drives fine at the speeds mentioned above, but the brakes do not like to stop me fast from 75. But mostly would like to be able to drive 65 and have the same econ as the 456 gears @75.
2nd reason
If (and the if is more like when) I step up to 35s I'm afraid the gear ratio on 456 with 35x12.50 tire will kill fuel econ and power. With that being said.
I highly rec rob@ rwkhaus. He did full rebuild on front and rear new ere thing and I have had mine for a year no issues.
Other things to consider.
The front locker I would(if I had to do it over) gone with a selectable front locker, turning with the jeep in 4lo and a front full time locker is a bitch and 6 quarters.
The rear lock I went with power track and it is awesome have NOTHING bad to say about it
Again hit up rob he is the man man!