First post on naxja, so go easy on me, but I'm definitely not gettin' into the I6 vs. V8 debate either. An important factor in the driveability (sp) equation (with any motor) is the trans. The aw4 automatic is pretty much a toyota trans; think efficiency over asthetics or comfort. My friend's 4.0 GC (far less miles) shifts like it's sittin in a lazy boy after smokin a bowl compared to my XJ, granted he's got a few more lb's. BTW I can't stand japanese cars, so don't get me wrong... If I was doing a complete swap for a different motor, there's no way I would consider putting in another 4 speed. Bolting in a stroker is one thing, but why spend all that money on a dialed in LS1 and still run a 4 speed hydramatic? Just my 2 cents...