dukie564
NAXJA Forum User
- Location
- Aberdeen, MD
Re: THe NAC Lots-O-Post Thread
The way I see it
a) they're not impacting the donor pool negatively at all - in fact they're helping it. The donors are typically people who are dead/dying (or family) - this guy is grabbing kidneys from living, breathing people, so it's not going to affect supply. In addition it's removing people from the waiting list, making the situation for the other people on the list BETTER, not worse.
b) If i needed a transplant, and had the opportunity to pay this guy to put in a new one without having to wait months on a list, would I do it? HELL YES. I'd do whatever i had to if it meant living on.
c) If i really needed money would I sell one of mine for $25k? Probably not, but if I REAAAAAALLY needed money - yea. And if other people want to do so more power to them - they're probably saving a life by doing so.
Since no one's talking about anything and we haven't done one of these lately, how about another moral dilemma.
Some guy recently got busted for running a kidney transplant operation. He was paying $25,000 to anyone who wanted to sell a healthy kidney, and was charging a shit-ton more than that to anyone who wanted to have a damaged kidney replaced. The facility where he was doing this was clean, modern, and well equipped; the guy himself had surgical training and all of his patients - donors and recipients - had no medical issues at all from the procedures.
What they actually nailed him for was profiteering - making a profit by unethical means.
One argument is that a private-practice organ transplant setup takes viable donors away from the organ-donor waiting list and restricts access only to those who can afford to bypass insurance/hospitals/etc.
The other argument is whether human organs are something you should be able to buy/sell like any other goods, as there's not really a legitimate market history for that.
Honestly I think if you wanted to sell your kidney for $25k, more power to you. And if you're willing/able to pay $150k out of pocket to get a new one put in, good for you too. As long as I never end up footing your future medical bills if something goes wrong.
And if you're the guy that has the training and facility to make that happen, even better.
Thoughts?
The way I see it
a) they're not impacting the donor pool negatively at all - in fact they're helping it. The donors are typically people who are dead/dying (or family) - this guy is grabbing kidneys from living, breathing people, so it's not going to affect supply. In addition it's removing people from the waiting list, making the situation for the other people on the list BETTER, not worse.
b) If i needed a transplant, and had the opportunity to pay this guy to put in a new one without having to wait months on a list, would I do it? HELL YES. I'd do whatever i had to if it meant living on.
c) If i really needed money would I sell one of mine for $25k? Probably not, but if I REAAAAAALLY needed money - yea. And if other people want to do so more power to them - they're probably saving a life by doing so.