I ran 33s and 4.56s on the highway with my 5 speed and got right around 3k RPM at 75. And my mileage went from around 16 around town to 14 on the highway. I'd stick with the 4.10s if you have a 5 speed. Otherwise, what everyone is saying about 4.56s and the AW4 is true.
The calculators are fine & all, but in real world use, I have found 33 and 4.56 to be a bit on the weak side(5-speed and AW4)... 31" with 4.56 (AW4) was fun, and my current rig on 30" (AW4) will get 4.56 as soon as I get some $$$ for a locker and alloy shafts.
If anything, gas mileage improved going from 33/3.55 to 4.56, and didn't drop much or any going back to 31".
agreed, i would like more gear w/33s than the 4.56s i have. my mileage is usually around 13-14 and have gotten 16-17 on the hwy. i also have some exhaust issues as well which could be contributing to this