MTB:FS or Hardtail

Which one for XC riding?

  • Full Suspension

    Votes: 9 69.2%
  • Hardtail

    Votes: 4 30.8%

  • Total voters
    13
gcurtis said:
Hahaha! Fat and getting slimmer, lycra-boy. Let me guess, you also ride one of those ass hatchets for a seat and shave those pretty girly legs so that you look good all uniformed up in your tights and glistening with sun screen. Dude, go ride in WeHo with Ryan Gaycrest already. We get it, there is no more need to bash it into our colletive conscious with photos of your ass crack in black form fitting fabric.

Jealous bastard! :smootch:

gcurtis said:
Oh yeah, dimensions. 28.2665 on pass and 30.7635 on driver's side

I guess they are measuring the length of the shaft to the inside edge of the WMS. I will try to look tonight and see.
 
gcurtis said:
I have a good seat you can have if you want it. That is if Cracker Seacrest doesn't ask for it first. Selle Italia Flite Gel with Ti rails - a real ass hatchet.

Picked up a WTB at lunch today. Thanks, but no thanks, after last night w/o being in the saddle for say 5 years or so, I don't need an ass-hatchet.
 
gcurtis said:
Hey, since you are trying to sell me axles, I'm going to hit you up for schwag for a dirt jumping contest we're putting on in September... just a heads up. ;)

I will see what I can do

I probably have some samples or something around here ;)

For some reason I think you would have hit me up whether I wasn't selling you axle shafts. You're just trying to justify it ;)
 
cracker said:
I will see what I can do

I probably have some samples or something around here ;)

For some reason I think you would have hit me up whether I wasn't selling you axle shafts. You're just trying to justify it ;)

Nah, I've got a couple in my back pocket already and I tend to keep business (even volunteer crap) and friends seperate... Hell, frankly I didn't know I would be "re-involved" in advocacy until last night. I thought I was retarded... er... retired.

All of this bicycle talk has gotten my all worked up. I'm going for a ride. Perhaps I can run over some dog walkers at Peter's Canyon. :D
 
As far as the original question goes, that is a hard call.

Fat ass would say a full suspension to make it smooth. You can either get a really nice hardtail or a fair full suspension bike. It depends on what you are riding as well. Fire roads don't need full suspension but hairy descents would. Your call.

Remi got a crazy deal on a full suspension bike I set him up with. His price range was a little hight than your though but I don't recall the details. He will post up with which Specialized he got.

I have, and enjoy, both hard tails and full suspension bikes.

I think I ride my Blur a little more than my hard tail but that is because the hardtail is set up as a single speed right now.
 
gcurtis said:
Nah, I've got a couple in my back pocket already and I tend to keep business (even volunteer crap) and friends seperate... Hell, frankly I didn't know I would be "re-involved" in advocacy until last night. I thought I was retarded... er... retired.

All of this bicycle talk has gotten my all worked up. I'm going for a ride. Perhaps I can run over some dog walkers at Peter's Canyon. :D

That's right!

Your in Tustin!

Peter's canyon sucks ass!

I wrote this review years ago

http://www.mtbr.com/trails/California-Allotherareas/PetersCanyonRegionalPark.html
 
cracker said:
Remi got a crazy deal on a full suspension bike I set him up with. His price range was a little hight than your though but I don't recall the details. He will post up with which Specialized he got.

Yeah, my price range was lower then yours was and at the end I ended up paying a little bit more then what you're considering (although not by much) and I got a specialized FSRxc Comp. Man that bike rocks! It's a lot more bike then I originally planned for, but it feels like it will last me for a while. Now if I could only get in shape and have more time to ride it!
 
karstic said:
I knew this was gonna turn into a bitch fest between you two. I can't wait til Johnny chimes in.

:gag:
 
I have had a couple of both and personally I prefer the FS with a FOX RL. I just bought a Cannondale Jeckyll 700 sx after getting my hardtail Jamis ripped off and I have to say this is the sweetest bike I have ridden yet. The lockout feature is great. Just my 2cents.
 
Hey Grant when are you going to set up a MNG @ Tustin Brewery?
 
Actually, Grant, Avery, and Curt know a lot more about bikes than I do.

When I started biking, my first three bikes were hardtails. I was a latecomer to full suspension. I finally got a 4" travel Intense Tracer, which was a great "lightweight" full suspension cross-country bike.

Then a couple of years ago, I moved up to a Intense Uzzi SLX, with 7" in the back and 5" in the front (I need a longer travel fork). It's a little heavy at 34 pounds, but I don't have any trouble climbing with it.

I've often thought of getting a hardtail as a second bike. But then I think, would I ever ride it? Full suspension is much better.

So what's my point? :dunno: A hardtail would be good to start off with. But if you keep riding, you WILL want to upgrade to full suspension. But I've known people to start off spending good money on a full suspension bike and then NEVER ride it. Then they get pissed off when they try to sell it and can't get near what they paid for it.

So you'd be better off with a hardtail, or maybe upgrading your bike (which would be difficult with a 1" steer tube) until you are sure that you want to continue riding.

Remi took the plunge and got a good FS bike. But he has ridden several times and is still enthusiastic (despite what we've put him through). So it was a good move for him.
 
I actually used to ride quite a bit. When I lived in La Habra Heights, I regulary rode Skyline, Turnbull, Schabarum trails. I rode the Julian MTB fesival a couple of times. Since I bought the house and got married I haven't done much of squat.

My current bike is a steel-frame Schwinn High Sierra (vintage '84 or '85). The only things left from the original compentry are the Sugino cranks and Suntour thumb shifters. Things are pretty much old and worn out. I would like a new bike I just don't know which way to go - hardtail or FS. Part of that reason is cause I rode some of the first generation Trek FS bikes (cantilever arm with an elastomer stack) down in Julian and they were a blast! but like Avery said I can get a really nice hardtail or a middle of the road FS for the price I want to pay.

I dunno
 
Back
Top