Spudly, I love your avatar. Classic, and very familiar.
I've been running 33" BFG ATs, mostly because that is what was on it when I bought it and they're not ready to be replaced. While they wouldn't have been my first choice, they have performed very well in all conditions including mud in some cases. The sidewall issue is a problem - one of mine has a chip with white cord showing through. I don't know if BFG has fixed that issue with the M/T KM2 tires, but those are what I'm leaning toward for my next set. They seem to be a great design with the mud-shedding traits of an M/T and the siping for wet conditions of the A/T. I don't really like mud, so I don't need something like a swamper. Rocks, dirt, street, wet street, sand, and snow are my needs, in that order.