Hey, thanks for your comments. They'll help clarify a few things.
These heavy duty fender flares are being sold on Ebay so that the buyer determines a fair value. These flares do have a number of improvements over other brands such as heavier gauge material, UV Resistant coating, and a tighter better looking profile. We can all agree that each Jeep Cherokee owner has a personal preference, "to each his own."
A) The problem with fit is that there are so many variables on our Jeep Cherokees. Every jeep these flares were fit to had differences in the sheetmetal. That made it impossible to determine a precise cut line to get the flares to fit exactly. The slightly wider dimension was used to allow for adequate material to allow triming to fit most Jeep Cherokees.
B) The molding imperfections are unfortunate. Imperfections are being highlighted so that there is nothing unexpected when the buyer sees their fender flares. The first set also had the most imperfections. Obviously, if these flares were produced again additional improvements would be made and imperfections would be eliminated.
C) A lot of Jeep Cherokees have fender flares that are not painted and they fade over time. It was important for these new fender flares to be UV Resistant so they wouldn't fade in the same way. The product used on this one set you mention does not paint. As you noticed, the other sets of fender flares are all using a Paintable UV Resistant Coating.
For anyone interested, there is a set of these flares posted on Ebay that are almost perfect.
Jeep Cherokee Off-Road Fender Flares MB3
One more set to go, then done.
Thanks, Doug