Thats my point exactly. Most American cars are plain, no personality. I like Camaros and unique cars but can you easily describe the difference between a taurus, neon, lumina, impala, regal, lincoln, cadillac, or any of the big suvs that are pretty much the same. American trucks of course are great, Dodge, GM, Ford are not the same trucks. We have consistently done that well, probably because the CAFE and various other enconomy/safety regulations are not applied like they are to US cars, since trucks are still defined as a work vehicle.
If you are talking about what has happened post 2004, I agree, Detriot has picked up the slack once again. The new Mustang, Crossfire, GTO, that weird Chevy 50's truck, and Hemi cars. These are all top of the line flagship models though. But, go back 2 years and you get boring US sedans, few exceptions. These cars, are all cool, top of the line flagship vehicles. The US
economy (i.e. most out there) cars are still boring. And the flagships Detroit has produced are just retakes of old models. Cool cars but nothing new they just went full circle. The Dodge Magnum, looks fun to drive but why is it different from my grandmas 70something V8 stationwagon she had forever. This is why the US makers can't compete except in (trucks/suv, obviously) modern muscle or economy
only in "red state" markets where import anything is unpopular. The Focus I can't understand, sure its fun (in a go-cart way) to drive but crappy & problematic.
Japanese cars have brand identity. Mazda is rotary

or rwd sedans/coupes. Subaru, all wheel drive with airplane (flat) engines useful for inclement weather. Toyota is reliable, practical (Matrix) sporty-efficient(they pioneered just in time manufacturing). Mitsu has put turbos on lots of 4cyl models (the SRT-4 owes its life to Mitsu). Nissan is (in the US) affordable quality. Honda I agree, least personality of any car, designed to blend in. The Japanese did not offer topothe line stuff here. Subaru wrx, the 350z, the RX8, Lancer Evos, their makers were wary of offering those here because they saw the US makers offering cheap crap rental cars models or a good pricier car that guzzles gas. It took them time to realize people might want something in between.
Statistically, Ford has at least 3 times as many recalls, defects per model as anyone. Chevy makes good engines but ugly cars, I like DC the best but still that neon, looks so different from fords. The Japanese have consistently produced low defect vehicles, high resale prices, regardless of your friends Sentra breaking down. Remember I like American trucks and Jeep but if I want a
car that looks good, runs a long time, gets good mileage, fast, I can't think of a US car that does that.
:soapbox:
While I am standing here, we are not discussing rice boys or other drivers. I love Jap sportscars but I can't stand the dorks who also do. BMW is hard to work on, but don't criticize BMW unless you have ever driven a windy road in one, their owners driving habits are irritating but the car is awesome.