flexj said:
Although I think I know what the response will be, I will throw this question out anyway. I have a front D60 hp and a D44 hp, both out of 78/79 F250's. My XJ has 35's currently and is my DD. I am planning on putting the 44 up front, selling the front 60 and a 60 in the rear. If I go up to 37's, maybe 38's, will the 44 hold up? I don't do alot of heavy wheeling, but when I go, I like to go. Will I regret selling the front 60? I kind of need the cash to finance the 44.
Who know's? Anyone have a crystal ball?
All I can do is talk about what I decided, and why, when I was in the same situation. I was changing front and rear axles, and I had a HP D60 for the front and both a semi-floating and a full floating D60 to use for the rear. I decided after a lot of measuring and thinking that the D60 was just too big for what I wanted, and there were too many compromises. It would be very heavy and I wanted to cut it down to the correct size, not run full width, and there was no room for the coil spring perches. Also, because it was a Ford D60, I couldn't put 35 spline stub shafts in it, so I would be running 30 spline Spicer stub shafts.
At this same time CTM came out with their new axle u-joint. I figured I wouldn't break a reverse cut D44 ring and pinion, or locker, and I would have more ground clearance and less weight with the D44. I could run Warn chromoly axles, which may not be as strong as Spicer D60 axles, but had to be damn close, and I would have chromoly rather than Spicer stub axles. The CTM u-joints complete the package. Since I don't have a V8, and I'm not a throttle jocky, I was satisfied that the D44 with those components would be plenty strong for me. So, I sold the HP D60, which along with the money I got for my well built D30/D44, paid for a Tera60 for the rear.
I run 35's, but wheel it hard in the rocks, and I may some day go to 37's (no time soon). The D44 with chromoly axles and u-joints is pretty stout, but if you use Spicer axles and u-joints the D60 is much stronger. A D44 with Spicer axles and U-joints is only marginally stronger than a D30 that uses 297x u-joints, you'll break an axle joint in the D44 about as often as you'd break one in the D30, although you have a much higher probability of breaking an inner axle or stub axle in the D30.
Would you be happy with the D44? More than likely. Would you ever wish that you'd gone ahead and put in the D60 while you had one? Who knows.