Very cool, I hope you find some time to get to the dyno.
A diverter valve is really designed for vehicles with a MAF sensor (such as most subaru's and mitsubishi's). Most of these vehicles will get a CEL if a BOV is installed before (or after even) a MAF because the ECU thinks the sensor just failed.
The BOV will only open when the throttle plate suddenly closes so the turbo doesn't surge and destroy it'self. In this case the compressed air is useless anyways. I hope that makes sense?
and I know they say never to put a BOV on those or Subarus
Yeah, I was familiar with how both of them work. I also knew that putting a BOV on a DV'd vehicle would make the ECU go nuts. I have a MKV VW GTI with the 2.0T and I know they say never to put a BOV on those or Subarus. I guess my question is why not recirculate the air that's already compressed to sort of give the turbo a bit of a jump start? Both valves release the pressure, but one puts it back into the pre-turbo intake ducting. It sounds like part of the reason you went with the BOV is that XJ's don't have a MAF... but I can't see a DV hurting an un-MAF'd engine.
Either way, awesome work and cool videos. Looking forward to ones with better sound.
How are the stock internals holding up to 8psi? I did some reading here and on PBB. The general consensus was that the much more than 6.5 psi will eventually lead to breakage (be it a cracked head, thrown rod, etc).
How are the stock internals holding up to 8psi? I did some reading here and on PBB. The general consensus was that the much more than 6.5 psi will eventually lead to breakage (be it a cracked head, thrown rod, etc).
Glad your engine is doing well.They're holding up just fine.
First of all, Boost doesn't kill an engine. Detonation and excessive power will. For example, the 8psi I'm running is about 50% more air flow from the turbo than a M90 roots blower running at the same 8psi. Because of that the turbo is simply flowing more air @ that pressure level than the blower. Simply put, thats why larger turbos are capable of more power than smaller ones... easy enough right?
On the other hand, the power level that I'm running I don't consider "dangerous" for this particular motor AS LONG AS it is tuned properlly and detonation free. Forged internals however will allow for higher power levels and will sustain mild tuning discrepencies/detonation without damage. This is why I put such an extensive push for good tuning and engine management. If done correctly, most factory motors can and will last a very long time with boost. Case in point...our 11:1CR 1.6L honda has dyno'd over 400whp and lasted the past 4 years on stock internals.
I agree that detonation and excessive power is what causes engine failure. So, assuming that the AF ratio is proper and the incoming air is cool enough (via CAI, intercooler, meth, etc), you won't get knocking. That's something that a good tuner will account for in configuring an engine. I couldn't agree more.
Here's where you lose me: If the intake air is at 8psig in a SC system or a TC system and the systems are identical, how will a TC flow 50% more
air?
Along those lines, more psi = more gas to maintain proper AF ratio (but you need to account for that in the pre-intake cooling (meth, IC, etc) because the intake air will be hotter). Excessive power can be generated by too much boost with proper tuning. No arguments there, right? So commutatively, more boost = more power; we all get that. Continuing in that direction, how much power is too much power for the 4.0 with stock internals and how much boost is required to get there? I'm not actually looking for an answer, but using the question as a tool of conversation... (but if you happen to know the answer, I'd be ok with that :laugh3![]()
Now I'm back with you: Larger turbos make more power because the exhaust gas flows more freely through the turbo and can spin a bigger turbine which can compress more intake air. I'm familiar with forged internals and their benefits too.
Once again, thanks for your help.
Funny you should mention a background in fluid dynamics. I have a BS in ME and my favorite class was thermo fluids. :laugh:AFR is important, but proper timing is more important. Too much timing and you'll get preignition/detonation, too little and you'll melt pistons/valves. It's up to the tuner to be able to read the engine and tune accordingly.
Without getting a masters in fluid dynamics, the easiest way to visualize this is understanding the relationship between pressure and flow which is exactly what a typical turbo compressor map will show you.![]()
For any given pressure ratio, a compressor (turbo or SC) will flow a specific amount of air. The larger the compressor, the higher flow. Just like how a 6.0L V8 will flow more air and produce more torque than say a 2.0L 4 cylinder simply due to it's physical size.
There are simply far too many factors involved to give a specific answer, but the general rule of thumb I like to use is that an increase of 100% over stock is about the maximum you'd want to go for any factory engine. However if you use my 1.6L honda in this equation though it should have blown up at 200whp, but does just fine @ 400. Every engine is different, it's really just up to how much risk your willing to take.
It sounds like you understand just fine. It's all about having fun, and turbo's are absolutely my crack. I've been addicted since I was 16. :confused1
How are you going about measuring knock?
Reading the plugs and proper tuning. As long as nothing is drasticly changed with the motor, there isn't a big need to worry about it after tuning.