Audi SB Com. "Green Police"--farce or test balloon???

joe_peters

NAXJA Forum User
I'm a bit disappointed in Cheap Trick for agreeing to that.
 
I believe this commercial actually hurt the move towards going green. Nothing upsets Americans more than being told what they can and can't do, the "green police" ad was just that. All it did was strike fear into people who are skeptical about the benefits of green and the people who are sitting on the fence about whether to go or how far towards going green.

Two first hand personal examples about being green:
1. I grew up just below the top of a hill in San Francisco. As a boy in the sixties would climb to the top were we would play. I remember not being able to see across the bay to the Oakland hills in the east bay as the sky was a rust colored brown. This was pre-smog on cars. As an apprentice mechanic in the early 1980's the older guys would lament about all the new technology that was killing the cars. That was the growing pains of testing and tweaking to get it correct. 40 years later the east bay hills are in clear view.

2. In 2001 I was working at an indoor bus yard were the fleet was composed of 100 M.A.N. buses that were of 1984 vintage. The fumes were terrible. I took an 8 yr hiatus courtesy of the USCG and returned to a new fleet of coaches. These buses have Cleair soot scrubbers and run 10% bio-diesel. The air is actually tolerable.

There is nothing wrong with clean air, clean water, and not having trash strewed all over the place. Three years ago San Francisco pased a resolution banning the use of plastic bags at grocery stores. The end of the urban tumble weed came about in the City. Drive down the interstate and one of the leading blights is plastics, bags and wrappers that are caught on the fences alongside the road. No more overheated buses as these would get sucked up and block the air flow across the radiator.

Yeah, that commercial did nothing but hurt the chances of growing green expanding to the fence sitters.
 
Audi was just aiming advertising at the smug self-righteous idiots that are currently panicking about the brakes on their Priuses.

I did like the shot at the end where they bust the cops. "We're better then EVERYONE"
 
Audi was just aiming advertising at the smug self-righteous idiots that are currently panicking about the brakes on their Priuses.

Exactly that.

I was only hoping it was going to be more in-your-face at the end. Ferrari, Viper, hell, I even would have cheered for a Hummer.

It kinda defeated the point: "You're all absolutely nuts, but we've got a car even you loonies will like..."

Robert
 
I saw a Prius with a sticker reading "The trouble with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people's money - Margaret Thatcher" at the grocery store today. I didn't quite know what to think.
 
I think it is satire... audi is not exactly pumping out hybrids...

Tongue in cheek type thing, if anything it pokes fun at a city like San Fransisco!
 
Environmentalists are like watermelons--Green on the outside, Red (socialist) on the inside.
 
I believe this commercial actually hurt the move towards going green. Nothing upsets Americans more than being told what they can and can't do, the "green police" ad was just that. All it did was strike fear into people who are skeptical about the benefits of green and the people who are sitting on the fence about whether to go or how far towards going green.

Two first hand personal examples about being green:
1. I grew up just below the top of a hill in San Francisco. As a boy in the sixties would climb to the top were we would play. I remember not being able to see across the bay to the Oakland hills in the east bay as the sky was a rust colored brown. This was pre-smog on cars. As an apprentice mechanic in the early 1980's the older guys would lament about all the new technology that was killing the cars. That was the growing pains of testing and tweaking to get it correct. 40 years later the east bay hills are in clear view.

2. In 2001 I was working at an indoor bus yard were the fleet was composed of 100 M.A.N. buses that were of 1984 vintage. The fumes were terrible. I took an 8 yr hiatus courtesy of the USCG and returned to a new fleet of coaches. These buses have Cleair soot scrubbers and run 10% bio-diesel. The air is actually tolerable.

There is nothing wrong with clean air, clean water, and not having trash strewed all over the place. Three years ago San Francisco pased a resolution banning the use of plastic bags at grocery stores. The end of the urban tumble weed came about in the City. Drive down the interstate and one of the leading blights is plastics, bags and wrappers that are caught on the fences alongside the road. No more overheated buses as these would get sucked up and block the air flow across the radiator.

Yeah, that commercial did nothing but hurt the chances of growing green expanding to the fence sitters.

So ban plastic items because there is a high percentage of lazy scum in the city ? THAT makes perfect sense, how about those people just man up and take responsibility for their actions. Pshh, nahhhh, it's not their fault the grocery stores use plastic bags.
 
...,how about those people just man up and take responsibility for their actions,...
If we could figure out a way to make that happen, probably 80% of the annoying things in life would just disappear.
 
So ban plastic items because there is a high percentage of lazy scum in the city ? THAT makes perfect sense, how about those people just man up and take responsibility for their actions. Pshh, nahhhh, it's not their fault the grocery stores use plastic bags.

Florida uses prisoners to clean that crap up. Not nearly enough prisoner labor going on. They are all volunteer workers. They volunteered to break the law. Make 'em work!
 
I hear cutting people's hands off reduces theft. Seems that isn't allowed here though, for many good reasons.
 
I hear cutting people's hands off reduces theft. Seems that isn't allowed here though, for many good reasons.

I heard caning reduces graffiti! :D
 
So ban plastic items because there is a high percentage of lazy scum in the city ? THAT makes perfect sense, how about those people just man up and take responsibility for their actions. Pshh, nahhhh, it's not their fault the grocery stores use plastic bags.

Hmm, just got back from a weekend in AZ and guess what? Well besides the boarded up businesses along Mill Ave there was urban tumble weeds all along HWY 60 on the drive to Gold Canyon. I'm lucky enough to get to travel alot and this is not just a San Francisco or California problem, but the whole country has this blight, and thus must be full of lazy scum.

San Francisco just decided to do something about it.
 
Back
Top